A company offers you contractor leads for $35 each. Another charges more for appointments. Which is cheaper? You cannot tell until you know which enquiries are qualified, who responds and how many become paid work.

Quick answer: Compare cost per qualified lead, cost per booked appointment and cost per sold job alongside raw cost per lead. Different contracting trades have different ticket sizes, service urgency and close rates, so one universal “good CPL” figure is misleading.

Three metrics you should calculate

Raw CPL = marketing spend ÷ all leads received.

Qualified CPL = marketing spend ÷ enquiries that match your agreed criteria.

Customer acquisition cost = relevant acquisition spend ÷ new customers actually won.

Use consistent periods and avoid counting the same lead twice when they call and also fill out a form.

Contractor example with real arithmetic, hypothetical inputs

Suppose a remodeling business spends $3,000 on acquisition in a month and records:

Funnel stage Count Effective cost
Raw enquiries 60 $50 per enquiry
Qualified project leads 20 $150 per qualified lead
Site visits/consultations 10 $300 per booked consultation
New signed jobs 2 $1,500 acquisition cost per customer

Those inputs are illustrative, not typical market benchmarks. The business must compare the $1,500 customer acquisition cost with its real gross profit per job.

A service plumber might close far more individual jobs at a lower average margin, making the appropriate economics different.

Define “qualified” before paying for leads

For HVAC, this may require a valid service location, equipment problem and available dispatch time.

For electrical work, it may require the correct service type, location and an estimate-worthy scope.

For remodelers, it may require a real property owner, realistic project type, timeline and budget compatibility.

Record why leads are disqualified. “Bad lead” should not mean “salesperson never called.”

Shared marketplace leads versus your own marketing

A lead bought from a marketplace may be shared or subject to platform terms. An enquiry from your own website or Google Ads campaign may be exclusive to your business, but you also bear the ongoing marketing cost.

Compare total economics and response capacity, not headline CPL alone. Read shared versus exclusive contractor leads and contractor lead generation services.

Lead response changes the cost equation

If the office misses calls, the number of raw enquiries may remain the same while booked jobs fall. Track first-response time, missed calls, appointment confirmations and estimates without next actions.

A connected CRM and follow-up system helps expose those gaps. It does not turn poor-fit enquiries into good ones; you still need appropriate targeting.

Build a one-page marketing economics review

At the end of each month, record:

  1. Total ad spend, agency management and tracked software costs.
  2. Raw and qualified new enquiries by source.
  3. Appointments booked, completed and cancelled.
  4. Estimates sent and projects won.
  5. Gross profit per completed job where accurately measured.
  6. Lost opportunities caused by no response or capacity.

Don’t choose the cheapest lead vendor; choose the source and process that can deliver profitable jobs you can actually fulfill.

Need a second opinion? Get a free Revenue Audit and one free fix.