You send dozens of quotes but win too few jobs. The instinct is to lower prices, buy more leads or train salespeople to push harder. That may not address the actual problem.

Quick answer: Calculate estimate close rate = signed jobs ÷ estimates delivered for comparable job types. Then separate issues with lead quality, scope, speed, pricing, communication and follow-up. A blended percentage across emergency repairs and major construction bids can mislead you.

Calculate close rate correctly

Suppose a contractor sends 30 estimates in a month and wins nine. The simple close rate is 30%.

That doesn’t tell the whole story. Three may be tiny maintenance jobs, while the remaining six are large renovations. Also distinguish estimates that are still open from those the customer has declined.

Track both count of jobs won and gross profit of jobs won, with consistent cohort dates when possible.

Compare like with like

Project type Typical decision challenge What to investigate
Emergency repair Speed and trust Missed calls, dispatch window, clear pricing
HVAC replacement Equipment options Explanation of options and financing if offered
Kitchen remodel Scope and confidence Portfolio, exclusions, timeline, decision-makers
Commercial bid Formal process Bid completeness, procurement and project fit
Electrical upgrade Safety and scope Inspection details and cost explanation

These are qualitative considerations, not invented industry close-rate benchmarks.

Ask why each estimate was lost

Use a small set of honest reasons: out of scope, out of territory, schedule mismatch, no response, price, competitor chosen, postponed or unqualified.

“Price” shouldn’t become the catch-all reason merely because a customer didn’t sign.

Improve your proposal handoff

Set an owner when the estimate is sent. Confirm the customer received it and knows how to ask questions. Use plain-English scope, assumptions, material choices and how revisions work.

An estimate should have a clear next action without pressuring a customer who is still comparing options.

Build stop conditions into reminders

If the customer replies, signs, opts out or declines, automatic “Have you decided?” messages must stop or change. Read contractor estimate follow-up.

Track estimates missing a next action, average follow-up interval and win rate by lead source.

Get help identifying the leak

At The Bot Man, I work on contractor CRM pipelines and follow-up so leads don’t vanish after the initial conversation.

Start with a free Revenue Audit and one free fix. You can make better decisions with a clean pipeline before spending more on ads.